Peeking under the hood of best practices

Why does one policy or practice work in a one place but not another?

This article is published in full on our LinkedIn newsletter, Let’s #TalkGreenSpace.

Written by Dr Meredith Whitten, Researcher-in-Residence at Parks for London


Successful ideas are infectious.

When a policy initiative renders success, other locales and institutions, understandably, aim to replicate it.

Sharing successful policies aligns with the parks and green spaces sector’s collaborative and knowledge-sharing approach. Borrowing ideas from others can reduce administrative costs and lead to quicker implementation than starting from scratch. This is all the more appealing given the uncertain budgets and under-resourced operations with which discretionary parks services operate.

Adopting policies and practices from elsewhere is not a new idea for the parks sector. In fact, the very idea of the public park was pioneered in Victorian England and later imported by countries around the world. A more recent example is the High Line in New York City, which has prompted a worldwide trend of elevated parks, including in London.

In theory, it works

Transferring success from one place to another underpins the ideas of policy transfer and so-called “best practices.”

Policy transfer means the movement of policy from one place to another; Dolowitz and Marsh (1996) define it simply as “the process by which actors borrow policies developed in one setting to develop programmes and policies within another.” This implies importing fully formed, ready-to-wear policies.

In a similar vein, best practices seek to borrow aspects of a programme, practice or policy that have successfully been tried or “validated” in another setting: “it worked there, why shouldn’t it work here?”

The notion of best practices is often attractive because the production of success stories can help policymakers or practitioners justify or get needed buy-in for adopting a policy or investing in a programme, project or other initiative.

Citing and referencing others’ previous or existing successful policies can also be important in legitimising policy projects. Some—such as risk-averse local government—prefer to wait for policy innovators and early-adopters to experiment and find success before they then transfer and adopt a policy.

But is this a good thing?

…

Subscribe to Let's #TalkGreenSpace for more articles like these.

We only use strictly necessary cookies, cookies that are required for the operation of our website. Carry on browsing if you're happy with this, or find out how to manage cookies on our Cookie Policy page.