Evidence Session for Public Parks

The Levelling Up, Housing and Communities Committee (DLUHC) held an evidence session on Wednesday 20 July examining a range of issues relating to public parks, including park usage and the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on parks, inequality of access to green space, and the funding of public parks and green spaces.

Horticulture Week reported the following:-

Following up on the previous committee’s report in 2017, the first question posed to witnesses was whether we had made any progress, with seemingly the same issues being discussed.

Ellie Robinson, head of urban green space, National Trust, argues this agenda has not been a priority.

Drew Bennellick, head of land and nature policy UK, National Lottery Heritage Fund agrees, arguing a combined vision across Government for the future of urban green spaces is needed.

Cllr Gerald Vernon-Jackson, chair of the sports, culture and tourism board, Local Government Association says his disappointment had come from the lack of involvement from the department of health. He says, “I’ve seen £100 million out of our budgets under all parties and increasingly council’s are just becoming social service units.”

Speaking about the Parks Action group Bennellick says the early meetings were constructive, but that ambitions to get that cross governmental departmental focus were unsuccessful due to lack of resources and high staff turnover.

Funding

Bennellick says that funding was small scale and puts councils into a costly bidding process.

Vernon-Jackson agrees, arguing that it’s often the “flashy” projects that “get a nice headline” which win the money. He says, “We’re having to make decisions about not cutting hedges. I can’t apply for funding to increase hedge cutting. It’s short term, not long term sustainable funding which is where the pressure is.”

On whether the areas who don’t receive so much funding are the more disadvantaged, Vernon-Jackson says it is not connected to this. He argues it is down to who is good at bidding, using Liverpool as an example. He says it is the small scale district councils often in rural areas who might lose out.

Robison agrees, arguing, “Bidding for funding is an inefficient process and waste of public money. It’s all fragmented and its short term, doesn’t allow them to have a long term overview.”

Robinson also argues that funding has been “wholly inadequate” and that projects like pocket parks are not “tackling core systemic issues”. While she argues that the investment required to level up green spaces over a ten year period is £5.5 billion, she also states this would have created physical health and mental well being benefits of £200 billion.

Putting funding into perspective, Peter Neal, independent consultant and planning expert says it costs between £2m to £5m to restore a historic park.

Investment

Bennellick states the National Lottery has invested £1 billion, restoring 900 parks, with an estimated £1.6 million spent per park. When considering there are 27,000 parks in the UK, he argues the money doesn’t go very far.

Talking about the Future Parks Accelerator, Bennellick notes they have so far invested £9m but have leveraged this by a further £30m. He argues we should look at how we can leverage the £30m parks fund similarly.

This is especially important as local authorities estimate that over the next three years 30% of parks will decline, as Bennellick notes.

Part of the Future Parks Accelerator, Bennellick highlights Newcastle, Plymouth, Nottingham, Birmingham and Edinburgh as great examples and notes that Sheffield University is analysing the success in those areas to provide useable data.

When asked, “The levelling up and regeneration bill introduces this concept of a national development management policy, should there be one for parks and open spaces?” Neal says yes, even though this may override local decision making where appropriate.

Making parks a priority

Dave Morris, chair of National Federation of Parks and Green Spaces argues parks need to be seen as the essential infrastructure they are. He says, “The government should bite the bullet and say this should be a statutory service properly funded through taxation. This is a rich country; there’s now 177 billionaires in this country with a total personal income of £710 billion which is going up every year. That’s not acceptable when budgets are being cut every year.”

Morris argues that taxing 5% of that £710 billion would finance the entire parks services throughout the country for 10 years.

Alan Law, deputy chief executive of Natural England says that we needed a cross policy funding mechanism, to allow local authorities to see parks and green spaces as assets that they invest in that provide a financial return. He adds that there would need to be a formal reporting mechanism linked back to statutory targets so they can see and measure progress.

Helen Griffiths, chief executive of Fields in Trust argues, “we’ve got to recognise green spaces as a core part of the levelling up agenda. When we are thinking about placemaking we’re not thinking about parks and green spaces through the lens of the parks department but looking at the multiple benefits – pride of place, climate resilience and health and wellbeing outcomes – that can be generated from them.”

Social prescribing

Law reports that there are 1,000 new social prescribing link workers in place, and that the NHS is working towards a goal of 900,000 people being referred to social prescribing by 2023/24. Law can’t confirm if they would hit this target. He argues to do so, they would need more investment in general, but also more investment in green spaces.

Morris argues it is down to the quality of green spaces. He states that in Tottenham the renovation of a park – including an important new cafe – with £4m National Lottery investment alongside £2.5m from the council has resulted in the usage of that park to triple. He argues, “every park should be a Green Flag Award standard.”

This would obviously need to be backed by funding, but Morris argues organisations and the public are behind its green spaces. He highlights the parks charter put together by the National Federation of Parks and Green Spaces which is backed by 24 national organisations. He also notes that in the last enquiry 322,000 signed a petition, and not long after Mail on Sunday launched a similar Save Our Parks petition which was signed by 20,000 supporters.

On whether the Government’s 25 year plan is adequate, Morris argues that it doesn’t say a lot about committing to green spaces and “needs to be stronger.”

Subscribers of  Horticulture Week can access the full article here. We will provide a further update once the government has responded to the findings of the committee.

We only use strictly necessary cookies, cookies that are required for the operation of our website. Carry on browsing if you're happy with this, or find out how to manage cookies on our Cookie Policy page.