Not an April Fool’s joke: the contradictions of parks

Parks are an essential infrastructure to society, but approaches to funding and managing them are often at odds with their service provision.

The evidence base for the multifunctional benefits urban parks provide continues to evolve. From climate change adaptation and mitigation to improvements in health and wellbeing to fostering social cohesion, parks contribute to addressing an incredible range of challenges facing cities and their residents. Given the often tenuous investment in these public spaces, parks deliver an outsized return on that investment. Yet, parks do not always provide a simple or straightforward solution to all urban ills. Despite overwhelming support, parks can be weighted with contradictions.

Urban parks and green spaces are recognised as critical for human and planetary health, yet typically are categorised as an amenity or discretionary service.

Indeed, parks support statutory services such as health, education and biodiversity, yet lack statutory status themselves and are vulnerable to budget cuts.

Parks provide needed space to be active, exercise, recreate and play team sports, yet they also are expected to be tranquil spaces that allow for quiet reflection.

A natural, rewilding approach to green space is championed, yet park providers receive complaints that parks aren’t manicured or highly maintained.

Many parks reflect cultural heritage and are managed as historic sites, yet new contemporary spaces and other types of green infrastructure are needed to green increasingly populated cities.

Green spaces can deliver a wide range of simultaneous uses, but in practice are sometimes managed for a single dominant use.

Engaging with nature is valuable for health and education, yet “keep off the grass” signs or fencing perpetuates nature at a distance.

Large, flagship parks play a crucial role in a city’s resiliency, yet it’s the local, informal and often smaller green spaces near home – nature at the doorstep – that urban residents engage with daily.

Accessibility is fundamental for people to realise the myriad benefits of parks, yet inequitable provision of parks creates a deficiency in access to nature for some urban residents.

Urban parks are promoted as democratic spaces open to all, yet their design, use and management can result in making some people feel unwelcome.

It is increasingly said that parks contribute to active, green travel, yet fences, railings and limited entry/exit points can make these spaces inconvenient to incorporate into a broader journey.

Green spaces are an integral part of the urban fabric, but we also expect them to be a respite from the city.

As much as, if not more than, any other infrastructure found in cities, urban parks support health, resiliency and vitality. Yet, contradictions about parks exist. Efforts to remedy those contradictions where possible should be a priority. Yet, we should be cautious about bestowing a mystical power or unrealistic expectations on parks. There is no one-size-fits-all approach to parks. What is consistent, though, is the need for active and ongoing investment and management for these critical spaces. Whether it’s April Fool’s Day or any other day of the year, that’s no joke.

We only use strictly necessary cookies, cookies that are required for the operation of our website. Carry on browsing if you're happy with this, or find out how to manage cookies on our Cookie Policy page.